Client Snapshot
Client
A direct-to-consumer, over-the-counter hearing aid brand (name withheld)
Business model
DTC eCommerce, high volume, older-adult customer base
Engagement
RMS embedded with the in-house marketing team, and went on to provide their Director of Marketing
Where they were
Returns running over 40% — roughly double the industry norm — and being tracked as an operations problem
How the Engagement Worked
The client brought RMS in to run project management inside the marketing team they already had. That’s usually where these relationships start: the client has people, they just need someone to hold the work together.
Then turnover hit, and initiatives landed that the remaining team didn’t have the capacity or the specialization to take on. Rather than pause the work while the company ran a hiring process, RMS took on more of it — up to and including providing their Director of Marketing.
The Challenge
The return rate was over 40%. The industry standard for OTC hearing aids sits between 20 and 25%. Every point above that came straight off the bottom line — the product came back, the sale reversed, and the cost of acquiring that customer stayed spent.
The number surfaced in an executive meeting, raised by the Operations manager. It was being tracked the way operations numbers get tracked: units out, units back. What nobody had asked was what the customer was thinking when they boxed the device up and sent it home.
Success Goals
Bring the return rate into the 20–25% industry-standard band
Understand why customers were returning devices, not just how many
Build a post-purchase journey that did more than sell the next thing
The Approach
Research — the question that changed the brief
The assignment was straightforward: optimize the post-purchase email and SMS journey. The fast version of that job is a template and an AI draft. Most of the sequence writes itself, it ships in a week, and it looks like work.
We asked a different question first: what does this customer actually need to know, and what do they want most?
That question doesn’t get answered in a marketing meeting. It gets answered by the people who talk to customers all day. So the research started with Customer Service — what are you hearing, what do people call about, what are they confused by. And when Operations raised the return rate in an exec meeting, the two halves connected. A post-purchase series can’t fix a product problem. But if these returns weren’t a product problem, a post-purchase series was exactly the right tool.
Digging into the return reasons confirmed it. Most returns weren’t product failures. A large share of customers simply couldn’t get the devices set up. Another group had expectations no hearing aid can meet — they didn’t understand their own hearing loss well enough to know what “better” was supposed to sound like. They tried the device, it wasn’t what they had pictured, and back it went.
Strategy
Treat the first 30 days as an education window, not a marketing window. Two things had to happen before a customer could fairly judge the product: they had to get it working, and they had to understand what to expect from it.
Build
- The post-purchase email and SMS series, rewritten from scratch — setup and how-to content sequenced to-1 the moment a customer would actually need it, not to a generic drip schedule
- Plain-language education on hearing loss itself, and on what adjusting to a hearing aid genuinely feels like in the first weeks
- A live outreach call from the customer service team: a real person checking in, answering questions in the moment, and — where the device honestly wasn’t the right fit — moving the customer to a different model instead of processing a refund
Measure
Return rate tracked monthly against the pre-change baseline, with Marketing, Operations and Customer Service all reading the same number for the first time.
Results
Return rate dropped from over 40% to just under 20% within three months — at or below the 20–25% industry standard
The outreach call created a path to a better-fitting device instead of a refund, turning some would-be returns into upsells
Marketing, Operations and Customer Service stopped working in silos. The returns number became something all three teams could act on, and the information flowed in both directions after that
Why It Worked
The brief was a template job. The answer came from a question. “What does the customer need to know?” sent the work to Customer Service and Operations before a single email got written. That’s the whole difference between a sequence that ships and a sequence that moves a number.
The number lived in Operations; the cause lived in the customer’s first week. No one owns that handoff by default, which is exactly why it goes unexamined.
Automation got most customers set up. A phone call caught the ones it didn’t. The customers on the fence needed a person, not another email.
Call to Action
If a number is sitting with one team while the cause sits with another, that gap is usually where the fix is. That’s the kind of thing an outside marketing partner is well placed to spot — we’re in every one of those meetings, and we’re not protecting anyone’s territory.